Daniella Castoria on West Side Story and the Power of Representation

October 16, 2025

By Eldad (Eldee) Eyimife, AGMA Communications Coordinator

Amongst the meaningful roles Daniella Castoria has performed on stage, she feels especially drawn to West Side Story. She resonates with the plot, seeing herself and her family in the characters. To her, the story of West Side Story does not end on the stage but follows her home and through her daily life. Through her role in West Side Story, Daniella has found a space for herself to embrace the identity that emanates from within.

Daniella became an AGMA member in June 2025, when she was cast in the role of Rosalia in the Los Angeles Opera’s West Side Story. Though this was not her first encounter with the Jets and the Sharks, bringing this iconic story to life on the grand LA Opera stage felt like a true blessing. This opportunity deepened her connection to a story that has long lived close to her heart, with her also stepping into the role of Anita.

Born in New York City, the very setting of West Side Story, Daniella feels the narrative lives through her. Her mother is from the Dominican Republic, and her father is Italian; a blending of worlds that mirror the cultural tension and harmony at the heart of the musical. “I see myself in both the Sharks and the Jets,” she reflects, “So much of what’s in this script rings true for me; it’s my family’s story. It reminds me of my mom, her sisters and my grandma Rosa, that strong matriarchal energy that holds everyone together. Especially in the role of Anita and Rosalia, I see that ache for family, that deep connection that never really fades.”

For Daniella, West Side Story is not just a musical, but rather a reflection of Hispanic lineage and the generational stories that shaped her and the members of her community. She adds, “I think it portrays Latin American people as real, complex individuals. It humanizes us. …West Side Story captures a wide range of Hispanic experiences and delivers a powerful message of hope that “There’s a place for us… somewhere a place for us.”

That line resonates deeply with Daniella. For her, it’s more than just a lyric, it’s a mirror reflecting her own search for belonging and her determination to carve out a place in an industry that often tries to define her before she can define herself.

“When you’re starting out, it feels like teachers want you to build your brand or fit into a box before you can break into the industry. For a long time, I was trying to figure out how it all worked without letting anyone shape me into something I’m not. I’ve trained in film, TV, voiceover, commercials, musical theater, and dance, and I come from more than one ethnicity, so I was already outside the usual mold. Honestly, I didn’t even know what the box was supposed to be. Eventually, I realized the real power wasn’t in resisting it, but in owning it on my own terms.”

She speaks with pride as she recalls embracing every part of her identity, her family, her culture, and her heritage. “The fact that I speak Spanish with my grandma, and that I stay in touch with my cousins in the Dominican Republic those are the things that make me who I am,” she says. “When I stopped overthinking what I should or shouldn’t do and simply embraced who I am, the right opportunities started finding me.” It’s a journey of self-acceptance that mirrors the soul of West Side Story: finding a place where you truly belong not by shrinking to fit a mold, but by standing boldly in your own truth.